Kyle Rittenhouse's book "Acquitted" is, obviously, a Rorschach test.
You look in to it, and you read what you want to take from it.
There are those who call him a "white supremacist killer", and others
who call him a vigilante - sometimes approvingly, sometimes not.
The book itself is apparently self-published, with author and journalist
Michael Quinn Sullivan being the co-author; in this kind of collaboration, the
risk is always that the voice of the author is lost, or alternatively the
co-author doesn't supply enough direction and the book wanders everywhere.
Thankfully, the book avoids that trap. It's not a doorstop (only 118 pages),
and the line formatting is, frankly, terrible, but it's very readable and
packs a lot in.
The first nine chapters - leading up to chapter ten which starts the events of
August 25th, 2020 - are an interesting, and at times sad, view into Kyle's
childhood and teenage years. His family was quite dysfunctional, with a
drugs-and-women depedent father, whom he has subsequently cut out of his life,
and a loving mother who nevertheless was terrible with money. Kyle and his two
sisters moved around houses a lot, didn't do very well at school given all the
disruption, and he recognizes that he was well on the way to delinquency. It was
the police cadets at school, and in particular the male role models he found there,
which brought him back (mostly) to the straight and narrow, with a new determination
to train as an EMT/firefighter. He qualified as a lifeguard, and was working
that job in Kenosha when "Saint" George Floyd expired in Minneapolis and the
BLM riots started, eventually spreading to that town in August.
Of the riots themselves, he describes being in town the day after the first riot,
and seeing both the destruction wrought, and the way that white and black citizens
got together in determination to clean up and repair that destruction. He and his
friend lent their efforts to the clean-up, but everyone was aware that the riots might
well restart that night, so he volunteered to stand guard at a car shop, equipped both
with his rifle (legally held) and his EMT kit.
Then the riots kicked off, violent thugs ran around burning and breaking the city,
and at some point Kyle was chased into a dead end by Rosenbaum, who grabbed for his rifle...
There's a joke going around Twitter that "Kyle Rittenhouse fired at three
random liberals, and two of them were pedophiles."
The
truth is a bit more nuanced, but Rosenbaum certainly had a record of
sex offending against minors, along with a lot of violence, and
Huber was a repeat domestic abuser, also with violence. Grosskreutz, the
sole survivor, had a list of lower-level offences. Certainly, it seems clear
that the two fatalities from Kyle's shooting were not individuals for whom
society should particularly mourn.
Nevertheless, Kyle's reflections on his actions that night were interesting.
He certainly doesn't celebrate them - he says that he wishes that night had never
happened, and with everything that followed it's hard to be sceptical about that wish.
In more detail, he wishes he hadn't chosen to go to Kenosha that night - but given that
he did, he doesn't regret bringing the rifle. He points out that given the level of violence
threatened and demonstrated towards him and others that night, the rifle likely saved his life -
from Rosenbaum's likely violence with him cornered, by stopping Huber from beating him any more
around the head with his skateboard, leading to head injury and long-term headaches, and
probably Grosskreutz by preventing him from firing the (illegally conceal-carried) pistol
he pointed at Kyle.
Interestingly, he also regrets a number of the things he said and did after being released
from jail on bail, during trial prep and during the trial itself. Some he details, some he
alludes to, but in particular he reflects on his naivety with regards to all the grifting
that happened around his case, and how his situation was presented in wildly different ways
across the media. In particular, he strongly resents Joe Biden whose PR campaign adverts
presented Kyle's case in a very different way to the actual facts.
A few people and organizations come out with a lot of credit. The juvenile detention
organization, which held him for just short of 10 weeks, bent over backwards to support him,
give good advice and guidance, and keep him safe. Things started to get dangerous when inmates
came in who had heard about Kyle's case, and the threats started. By the time he was transferred
to adult jail in Kenosha, there were already outside organizations briefing inbound prisoners on
Kyle, with the clear implication to cause him physical harm. An additional three weeks in effective
solitary confinement in the Kenosha jail was even less fun, though again the guards were
professional and kept him safe.
Mark Richards, the lead defense counsel in Kyle's case, seems to be a remarkable man, and one of
the few lawyers whom I think I could respect. He agreed to write the foreword in Kyle's book, and
unlike many other forewords, this is very worth reading. In particular, he notes:
Kyle is 1 of only 3 clients I have represented in a murder case where I personally believed
the individual was truly not guilty of what he was charged. [my italics]
Kyle clearly admires Richards, describing him as an incredibly focused man, unafraid to be blunt
with his client, a hard taskmaster in trial preparation, and frequently calling out Kyle on his
bad judgements. Corey Chirafisi, co-counsel, was also greatly valued by Kyle; as a former prosecutor,
his practice court sessions quickly showed Kyle how to present himself in court, how to avoid being
tripped up too often, and warn him about different strategies the prosecution could use to elicit
damaging testimony from him. Crucially, Kyle described the subsequent trial as holding "no surprises".
The defense team was not pro bono; Kyle was fortunate that his case had caught enough media
attention, and that the available facts e.g. from the videos that night, seemed to corroborate his
case. A substantial defense fund was raised, and spent, in addition to the $2 million in bail that
Kyle was required to raise before being released. Donors from all across the country effectively
prevented Kyle from being railroaded into a multi-decade jail sentence. One wonders how many others
without such support have not been so lucky.
The prosecution lead, Assistant District Attorney Thomas Binger, no doubt wishes he'd never taken
this case to prosecute. I didn't realize at the time, but Kyle (presumably from Mark Richards'
observations) noted that the District Attorney had passed on the case - and likely because it
quickly became clear that there was a lot of photographic, video and then forensic evidence on
Kyle's side. Binger is infamous in the trial coverage as having a strip torn off him by the
judge when he repeatedly tried to introduce Kyle's use of his right to silence - which is a big
no-no. Kyle clearly doesn't like Binger, which is no surprise, and takes some relish in pointing
out that none of the prosecution witnesses helped Binger's case, and some actively helped Kyle.
The rest is history. Kyle did okay on the stand, Richards and Chirafisi did a rock-solid presentation
of the defense facts and argument, the jury came back after four long days with unanimous
"not guilty" verdicts.
The ending is fairly bittersweet. Kyle has won his case, and has his freedom, but is unable to take
up his desired career (EMS/firefighter) for the forseeable future, until his notoriety reduces.
There are still civil cases pending from the families of the people he shot, so the remaining money
his case raised will probably be eaten up by defending those.
He still has panic attacks from the night, but has a support dog Milo who helps him with this.
He has started a job as a entry-level political consultant, which I guess isn't a bad choice given the
experience he has had with politics - on both sides.
"Acquitted" is available on Kindle from Amazon, and from
rittenhousebook.com in paperback. If you care
about the American justice system, and the truth, it's worth
your time to read.
