UC Berkeley is a focus for repression of free speech

Last night, the famed right-wing polemicist Milo Yiannopoulos was intending to speak at the University of California at Berkeley. It turns out that there are some people who would prefer that Milo not speak. Rioting, toppling light poles, beating up and pepper-spraying Milo/Trump supporters

It's a sad statement of today's political environment that I was nearly astounded to see UCB's Chancellor actually defending a decision not to cancel Milo's visit. After a rash of spineless cancellations of speaking invitations for Milo - and also for Ben Shapiro, who is much less provocative than Milo but still apparently prone to trigger mouth-frothing by university faculty - it's nice to see a university chancellor sticking up for the principle of free speech. The "right not to be offended" is a particularly pernicious concept and it was refreshing for it to be given short shrift.

Of course, the "anti-fascist" movement was not keen to let a Milo event pass unremarked, and duly turned up to riot. The violence caused the university to cancel the event, thereby providing a perfect example of the "heckler's veto". If you don't like someone's speech, just protest violently and their event will be cancelled. I can't see any problems arising from the incentives this has provided at all, no...

There was only one arrest as a result of the rioting. This is what worries me the most - that rioters not only get the effect they deserve, but can perpetrate their violence practically free of consequence. There's only one direction for future violence as a result, and it's not "down".

1 comment:

  1. There was an interview with Bonnie Reiss on BBC R4 World Tonight: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08byp9q Start listening at about 21 minutes in.

    Her only regret (IMO) was that all the demonstrations did was generate beneficial publicity for Yiannopoulos.

    Mind you, the interview wasn't exactly forensic and the interviewer didn't ask her to condemn violence, or try to draw comparisons between Trump and the demonstrators regard of the constitution....


All comments are subject to retrospective moderation. I will only reject spam, gratuitous abuse, and wilful stupidity.